In contracts of employment, non-compete clauses seek to restrict the employee from engaging in activities which are in competition with those of the employer and may contain restrictions with respect to time, geography or area of business. Many employers in India rely on a non-compete clause to stop an employee from moon lighting or a departing employee from joining a competitor. However, Indian law gives employers far less protection than most expect, and understanding the limits before a key employee resigns is important to protect the business and manage risk.
The legal enforceability of such clauses is often debated on the touchstone of the common law doctrine of ‘restraint of work’, which on the other end, seeks to preserve an individual’s freedom to engage in a trade, profession or business of their choice. Indian law protects an individual’s freedom to earn a living more strongly than most legal systems. The legislative expression of this doctrine is found in Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 which states that, “Every agreement by which any one is restrained from exercising a lawful profession, trade or business of any kind, is to that extent void”. The statutory exception to this provision is an agreement to not carry out a similar business of which the goodwill is being sold. The Indian courts, unlike their British or Singaporean counterparts, will not enter into an analysis of whether the restriction is general or partial, and will also not apply the test of reasonableness to the non-compete clause (unless it falls within the exception engrafted in Section 27).
The Supreme Court has held different considerations apply against restrictive covenants of non-compete which are operative during the term of contract and those which extend beyond its cessation. In Niranjan Shankar Golikari v. Century Spg & Mfg Co. Ltd., AIR 1967 SC 1098, the employer obtained an injunction against an employee who had agreed to serve for a fixed term and then tried to work for a rival during their contract period. The restriction covered only the period of employment and only work similar to the employee’s role, so the court held it reasonable and necessary to protect the company. Here, courts are to step in only when the terms are unconscionable, excessively harsh or one-sided.
As a general rule, negative covenants such as non-compete clauses operating post cessation of the contractual term are hit by Section 27 and are thus void. This has been held in a long line of cases. For instance, in the case of Percept D’Mark (India) v. Zaheer Khan, AIR 2006 SC 3426, an appeal on an interlocutory application was made to the Supreme Court regarding a right of first refusal clause in a promotion contract. The clause granted the appellant agent a right to match any third party offer made to respondent Zaheer Khan with respect to the subject matter of the promotion contract, in which event Zaheer Khan would be obliged to enter into an agreement with the agent on similar or better terms than the third party offer. It was held that this clause, if read to be operational after the contractual term, was a negative covenant in restraint of trade. In VFS Global Services Private Limited v. Mr. Suprit Roy, 2007 SCC Online Bom 1083, the garden leave clause required the employee to not work in a similar business for a period of three months which were to commence after the employee has served the period of notice and upon his having ceased to be on the rolls of the Company. Since the covenant operated post termination of employment, the clause was held to be unenforceable.
Although Section 27 is rigid on paper, Indian courts have found ways to reach fair results in practice. In Affle holdings Pte Limited v. Saurabh Singh, 2015 SCC OnLine Del 6765, a Share Purchase Agreement (SPA) was entered into in order for the petitioner company to purchase controlling interest of the company from the respondents. Along with this, respondent 1 was employed as managing director and was under an obligation to not engage in a competing business during the course of his employment or for a period of 36 months after the SPA was executed. The petitioner was held to have paid substantial consideration to respondent 1 with a view to acquire the company business along with its goodwill, bringing this case under the exception to Section 27. The non-compete agreement was held to be reasonable as to the restriction in terms of time period and was therefore upheld. In M/s Kouni Travel (I) Pvt. Ltd V/s Mr. Ashish Kishore, 2007 SCC Online Bom 1604, the court granted an injunction on the basis of a non-compete clause operating after the contractual term due to the respondent being compensated for the time duration of the garden leave clause. Further, the restriction was limited to a certain time duration (a crucial period for the employer company) and to a certain business area. Thus, courts weigh what a restriction aims to protect and distinguish between different kinds of clauses based on facts.
It is recommended that the inclusion of non-compete clauses operative after the term of contract in employment contracts governed by Indian law be avoided as a regular practice (unless covered by the statutory exception), as enforcement is unlikely. If incorporated, it is desirable to ensure restrictions on the employee are the bare minimum necessary for the protection of the legitimate interests of the employer and are justified by factors such as fair compensation or the significant role of the employee in the company. This does not mean employers do not have the means to protect their business from their employees. Zhong Xing Tan and Umakanth Varottil, who reviewed around 150 years of Indian case law, note that courts treat clauses protecting trade secrets, confidential information and non-solicitation clauses differently from a general ban on competing, and enforce them more readily. Minimum service bonds have also been held as valid. In Vijaya Bank & Anr. v Prashant B. Narnaware, 2025 INSC 691, the court upheld a minimum-service bond with liquidated damages of Rs. 20 lakh for premature resignation and held that it did not violate Section 27. This was because the penalty amount was held to be proportionate to the salary and investment of the company in the employee.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice.




